Thursday, February 8, 2007

What if...

What if Scrooge was nice from the very beginning? What would the situation be like? I personally think that he would have tons more friends and that the spirits wouldn't of visited him. Would Marley still be alive?

11 comments:

gollum said...

he probably would. but if he was, there would be no story. so even if u want him 2, he cant b

Heat Seeker said...

That would be totally pointless if Scrooge was nice all the way through. If that had happened there would have been no story.

Barzul

laura said...

If Scrooge was nice, there would be no conflict and his character would be different. So either there would have to be a new character to start a conflict, or one of the other characters would have to be changed. Either way, the conflict and point of the story would be completely different.

Chan said...

Yeah, Marley might have been alive!!!


That would be awsome!!!

^^

Visit MINE!!!

Jacob said...

If scrooge was nice would if the spirits came to teach him how to be mean

Stephanie said...

That would be strange! I never thought of that. He probably would have married Bell and had a brood of kids. Bob Cratchet would probably also be really well off.I wonder who the spirits would have visited? But then, if he were nice, Christmas wouldn't have been saved!

Anna-bug said...

the fact is, that the book wouldn't have even been written if he was nice from the beginning. what's the point of writing a story, if you don't have a conflict?

Koko said...

It would've been sooooooo much cooler if he became mean instead of nice! Then...then...acctually that would be a lame story...no wait! It could work...
OH NEVERMIND!! The book's already written anyways, so this question is pointless!
Koko
P.S. VISIT MINE!!!

Sacha said...

I't would be really bumb because there wouldn't be a good plot. Well write me back i'm a bit bord.

Medhive said...

If Scrooge became evil by the end, that would be sweet

Bethy said...

There would be no story if he were nice! Marley would only be alive if he was nice to, but if he was mean he would still be dead!